PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

Theoria. Revista de Teoría, Historia y Fundamentos de la Ciencia

Volume 3, Issue 1/2/3, Octubre/Septiembre 1987/1988

Lorenzo Peña
Pages 67-94

Un enfoque no-clásico de varias antinomias deónticas

Three (apparent ) deontic antinomies are discussed: the paradoxes of the watchman and the praiser, as weIl as deontic dilemmas. A paraconsistent deontic logic, Ad, is put forward whose underlying 1st-order calculus is an infinite-valued tensorial logic. Several arguments are offered bearing out be existence of deontic contradictions, while two ways of dealing with conditional obligation paradoxes within the framework of Ad are canvassed. While the aggregation rule and the ought-implies-can principle are upheld, sundry schemata are shown not to obtain which involve iterated deontic operators (most conspicuously: that whatever ought to be obligatory is obligatory; and that it is obligatory that whatever ought to be the case should in fact be the case).

Usage and Metrics