PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

Teaching Philosophy

ONLINE FIRST

published on April 8, 2014

Christopher A. Pynes
DOI: 10.5840/teachphil20144414

Seven Arguments Against Extra Credit

Overwhelmingly, students desire the opportunity to earn extra credit because they want higher grades, and many professors offer extra credit because they want to motivate students. In this paper, I define the purposes of both grading and extra credit and offer three traditional arguments for making extra credit assignments available. I follow with seven arguments against the use of extra credit that include unnecessary extra work, grade inflation, and ultimately paradox. I finish with an example of a case where extra credit could be justified, although it relies on an important equivocation. Ultimately, I show that extra credit is neither a pedagogically sound nor a conceptually coherent grading practice, and I conclude that extra credit should not be part of the pedagogical toolbox.

Usage and Metrics
Dimensions
PDC