Volume 25, Issue 2, Fall 2021

Rethinking Phenomenology with Edith Stein

Ioannis Trisokkas
Pages 125-154

Phenomenology as Metaphysics
On Heidegger’s Interpretation of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit

The article reflects on Heidegger’s “metaphysical” interpretation of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit. This interpretation is driven by two theses Heidegger holds: (1) that the Phenomenology is a necessary part of Hegel’s “system of science” and (2) that the Phenomenology is metaphysics. These two theses contrast with Houlgate’s “epistemological” interpretation, which claims that the Phenomenology is not a necessary part of Hegel’s system of science and that it is not metaphysics. The article shows that while Heidegger has an argument that establishes, contra Houlgate, his second thesis, this very argument has consequences that undermine his first.