Volume 5, Issue 2, 2018
Skeptical Problems in Political Epistemology
Scott F. Aikin
Dialecticality and Deep Disagreement
In this paper, I will argue for a complex of three theses. First, that the problem of deep disagreement is an instance of the regress problem of justification. Second, that the problem of deep disagreement, as a regress problem, depends on a dialecticality requirement for arguments. Third, that the dialecticality requirement is plausible and defensible.