Southwest Philosophy Review

Volume 39, Issue 2, July 2023

Susan V. H. Castro
Pages 1-5

Considering the Scope, History, and Sophistication of Skilled Action in Expertise

In his paper “Getting Sophisticated: In Favor of Hybrid Views of Skilled Action in Expertise,” Spencer Ivy (2023) argues effectively for what he calls a “sophisticated hybrid” view of expertise, driven by empirical considerations and argument from contemporary phenomenology and cognitive architecture. Here I raise three unfair objections which I think lead to some fair questions that may be productive for discussion and future work.