PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

Studia Phaenomenologica

Volume 12, 2012

Possibilities of Embodiment

Dan Arbib
Pages 383-397
DOI: 10.7761/SP.12.383

Donner la mort ? Phénoménologie et sacrifice Note sur une interprétation de Derrida

This article claims to dispute Derrida’s interpretation of Isaac’s sacrifice proposed in Donner la mort by means of three sources: 1) midrashic sources, which impose to read the sacrifice not as a requirement of murder, but as sacrifice of the sacrifice; 2) the phenomenology of Levinas which allows to measure the violence of the interpretation of Derrida and to return the biblical episode to the complications of the relationships between ethics and rationality; 3) the phenomenology of Marion, which, by refusing to interpret this biblical episode as a sacrifice following its common concept, proposes a phenomenological interpretation which returns the sacrifice to the conceptuality of the gift and donation, considered as impossible by Derrida. Far from being conflicting ways, these three layers of analysis can be capitalized and mutually validated.

Usage and Metrics
Dimensions
PDC