PDC Homepage
Home » Products » Purchase

Philo

Volume 5, Issue 1, Spring-Summer 2002

Christopher McHugh
Pages 94-102

A Refutation of Drange’s Arguments from Evil and Nonbelief

In this article, two of Theodore Drange’s atheological arguments against the God of Christianity are refuted by what I call the “Expectations Defense.” By means of this defense, it is shown that, despite what Drange argues, the existence of evil and unbelief cannot be used as evidence against the existence of the God of the Bible. The fact that biblical history describes God as allowing there to be vast amounts of evil and unbelief prevents us from citing the existence of those things as evidence against the existence of the biblical God. Quite simply, we should expect there to be great amounts of suffering and doubt if the God of the Bible exists. As a result of this, it follows that Drange’s arguments are unsound, and should be rejected by rational people.

Usage and Metrics
Dimensions
PDC