Environmental Philosophy

Volume 2, Issue 2, Fall 2005

Ted Toadvine
Pages 61-71

Gestalts and Refrains
On the Musical Structure of Nature

Western philosophy and culture have often posited a structural homology between music and nature. In a contemporary version of this association, deep ecologist Arne Naess proposes that the basic units of reality are hierarchically nested gestalts of a fundamentally relational character. I argue that Naess’s gestalt model fails to account for non-holistic or non-sensical experiences and for creative change in nature. I then suggest the concept of the “refrain” developed by Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari as the basis for an alternative musical model of nature that avoids these limitations.

Usage and Metrics