PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

Philosophy in the Contemporary World

Volume 20, Issue 2, Fall 2013

Tim Johnston
Pages 28-37

Holding Well and Holding Open
Bergson and Parental Deliberations on Neonatal Genital Normalization Surgery

This essay is a philosophical analysis of a parent's decision whether or not to consent to neonatal genital nomalization surgery for a child bom with ambiguous genitals. Using Henri Bergson's analysis of duration, I make the distinction between spatialized narrative snapshots, and attention to duration, A spatialized narrative snapshot is a speculative picture of the child's entire life. Attention to duration requires we acknowledge that as long as the child is alive her life is indeterminate. I then take Hilde Lindemann's concept of holding and develop it to help parents understand attention to duration in order to resist the pressure to consent to genital normalization surgery.

Usage and Metrics
Dimensions
PDC