PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

The Journal of Philosophy

Volume 114, Issue 2, February 2017

Joe Horton
Pages 94-104
DOI: 10.5840/jphil201711427

The All or Nothing Problem

There are many cases in which, by making some great sacrifice, you could bring about either a good outcome or a very good outcome. In some of these cases, it seems wrong for you to bring about the good outcome, since you could bring about the very good outcome with no additional sacrifice. It also seems permissible for you not to make the sacrifice, and bring about neither outcome. But together, these claims seem to imply that you ought to bring about neither outcome rather than the good outcome. And that seems very counterintuitive. In this paper, I develop this problem, propose a solution, and then draw out some implications both for how we should understand supererogation and for how we should approach charitable giving.

Usage and Metrics
Dimensions
PDC