Volume 16, Issue 1, Spring 2011
Truth, Reality and Religion New Perspectives In Metaphysics
Louis Caruana, S.J.
Claims are universal when they are not dependent on when and where they are made. Mathematics and the natural sciences are the typical disciplines
that allow such claims to be made. Is the striving for universal claims in other disciplines justified? Those who attempt to answer this question in the affirmative
often argue that it is justified when mathematics and the natural sciences are taken as the model for other disciplines. In this paper I challenge this position and
analyze the issue by looking at it from a new angle, a perspective that involves two key concepts: violence and loyalty. The result of this analysis throws light on the
broader question concerning what the search for truth might mean in a pluralistic world.