PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly

ONLINE FIRST

published on November 28, 2017

David S. Oderberg
DOI: 10.5840/acpq20171127135

The Storage Problem Revisited
Reply to Díaz

Antonio Ramos Díaz has recently given an extensive critique of what I have called the “storage problem” for materialism about the human mind. I respond to Díaz, showing that his critique fails. First, I rehearse the storage problem, explaining what claims it does and does not involve. I then consider Díaz’s “strong” and “weak” interpretations of my argument, explaining why I do not subscribe to the strong version, which misinterprets my position, especially concerning the meaning of the term “concrete.” His weak version of my argument is closer to what I intend, but Díaz’s own unpacking of this interpretation also commits me to claims I do not, for very good reasons, accept. Díaz does not, in the end, show the storage problem to be—as he thinks—an unsound way of arguing for dualism. Getting concepts into a purely material human intellect still looks like the metaphysical equivalent of fitting a square peg into a round hole.

Not yet a subscriber? Subscribe here
Already a subscriber? Login here

This document is only accessible with a subscription