PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

Res Philosophica

Volume 91, Issue 1, January 2014

Modern Philosophy

Marleen Rozemond
Pages 1-28
DOI: 10.11612/resphil.2014.91.1.1

Mills Can't Think
Leibniz's Approach to the Mind-Body Problem

In the Monadology Leibniz has us imagine a thinking machine the size of a mill in order to show that matter can’t think. The argument is often thought to rely on the unity of consciousness and the notion of simplicity. Leibniz himself did not see matters this way. For him the argument relies on the view that the qualities of a substance must be intimately connected to its nature by being modifications, limitations of its nature. Leibniz thinks perception is not a modification of matter because it is active and matter is passive. At the same time, there are traces in Leibniz of a different argument that relies on the notion of internal action, which may involve the notion of simplicity. Critics have sometimes charged that the Mill Argument is an argument from ignorance, but Leibniz was aware of this problem and made clear that he did not make that mistake.