PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

Philosophia Christi

Volume 22, Issue 2, 2020

Spencer Case
Pages 307-321

Small Evils and Live Options
A New Strategy against the Argument from Evil

Many philosophers have thought that aggregates of small, broadly dispersed evils don’t pose the same sort of challenge to theism that horrendous evils like the Nazi Holocaust do. But there are interesting arguments that purport to show that large enough aggregates of small evils are morally and axiologically equivalent to horrendous evils. Herein lies an intriguing and overlooked strategy for defending theism. In short: small evils, or aggregates of such evils, don’t provide decisive evidence against theism; there’s no relevant difference between horrendous evils and aggregates of small evils; hence horrendous evils must not provide decisive evidence against theism, either.

Usage and Metrics
Dimensions
PDC