Volume 14, Issue 1, 2012
Alvin Plantinga's New Argument Against Materialism
Francis J. Beckwith
Zygotes, Embryos, and Subsistence
A Response to Corcoran
This article is a response by the author of Defending Life, Francis Beckwith, to Kevin Corcoran’s critical review of that book. In his review Corcoran maintains that Beckwith provides only a “typical” genetic code argument for the zygote’s individual humanity, and that Beckwith fails to show that there exists an individual human organism that subsists from conception and develops into a mature version of itself. Beckwith argues that Corcoran is mistaken on both counts.