PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

Philosophia Christi

Volume 11, Issue 2, 2009

Religious Diversity: A Dialogue

Warren Shrader
Pages 377-396
DOI: 10.5840/pc200911235

Dembski’s Specification Condition and the Role of Cognitive Abilities

This paper brings recent work in virtue epistemology to bear on the debate over design inferences. I intend to show that certain objections to William Dembski’s explanatory filter, in particular his specification condition, are on target, but that incorporating into the specification condition a notion borrowed from virtue epistemologists (a cognitive ability) makes the condition more understandable and immune to the criticisms that have been offered. I conclude by suggesting a way that one might flesh out the notion of a cognitive ability and revise Dembski’s account accordingly. This helps to advance the debate over design inferences.

Usage and Metrics