PDC Homepage

Home » Products » Purchase

The National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly

Volume 17, Issue 4, Winter 2017

Daniel Patrone
Pages 633-648
DOI: 10.5840/ncbq201717465

Compensation for the Moral Costs of Research-Related Injury

In the United States, researchers are not legally required to compensate trial participants for research-related injuries. Nevertheless, institutional review boards (IRBs) ought to require that all research proposals include broad compensation plans. However, the standard justifications for mandatory compensation cannot reconcile the need for adequate participant protections with a duty on the part of the research community to provide them. This situation can be resolved only through a deeper analysis of research-related costs. Once mere costs are distinguished from moral costs, a compelling case can be made that the principle of respect for persons, or human dignity, provides a sound moral foundation for assigning responsibility for research-related injuries.