Logos & Episteme

Volume 14, Issue 3, 2023

Frederik J. AndersenOrcid-ID
Pages 243-259

Uniqueness and Logical Disagreement (Revisited)

This paper discusses the Uniqueness Thesis, a core thesis in the epistemology of disagreement. After presenting uniqueness and clarifying relevant terms, a novel counterexample to the thesis will be introduced. This counterexample involves logical disagreement. Several objections to the counterexample are then considered, and it is argued that the best responses to the counterexample all undermine the initial motivation for uniqueness.