PDC Homepage
Home » Products » Purchase

Journal of Philosophical Research

Volume 37, 2012

Ben Colburn
Pages 233-241

Autonomy-minded Anti-perfectionism
Novel, Intuitive, and Sound

John Patrick Rudisill purports to identify various problems with my argument that the state promotion of autonomy is consistent with anti-perfectionism, viz., that it falsely pretends to be novel, is unacceptably counterintuitive because too restrictive and too permissive, and that it deploys a self-defeating formal apparatus. I argue, in reply, that my argument is more novel than Rudisill gives me credit for; that properly understood my anti-perfectionism implies neither the implausible restrictions nor the unpalatable permissions that Rudisill claims; and that my formal apparatus is innocent of the flaws imputed to it.

Usage and Metrics